3 Carnegie, George, and Lloyd offered sharply contrasting characterizations of
rich people and the social consequences of their wealth. What accounted for
their differences? How would George and Lloyd have replied to Carnegie and
vice versa?
What can you detect about Kirkman’s, Sumner’s, and Carnegie’s views of
democ racy?
How did George’s and Lloyd’s views of democ racy differ? To
what extent did these men believe democ racy and freedom were compatible?
What did they think was the proper source of political power?
